3 Comments
User's avatar
SocraticGadfly's avatar

Several thoughts.

1. On the round-ups, language is an identifier, first, and second, we know what ICE does. So, you can't say "they arrested 300 people." Sorry, KOAA; I disagree. I think "undocumented" is preferable indeed, to "illegal," though.

So, why not use the old anti-libel hedge term "allegedly" in front of "undocumented immigrants"?

2. Note to Kyle Clark: Ukraine's Zelensky shut down media outlets after the start of the war. And before the start of the war. https://socraticgadfly.blogspot.com/2022/03/russia-ukraine-thoughts-week-2.html Hard pass on a TV station anchor doing that. Were I program manager (not that actual leftists get to do that) it would be verboten.

Expand full comment
Corey Hutchins's avatar

I initially almost used "rounded up" in the headline and "roundup" in the story and then changed it to avoid using dehumanizing language when writing about dehumanizing language.

Expand full comment
SocraticGadfly's avatar

I can see that, and wasn't thinking about that. I might not in a newspaper story myself.(Edit: At the same time, "Round-up" is used in many non-criminal stories and discussions. One of the school districts in my newspaper coverage area has a "kindergarten round-up" before the start of the new school year every year.) I don't know your take on my primary point.

As for Kyle Clark, if you see him, to double down on what I said. Tell him to Google the names of Palestinian journalists killed by Israel and see what ties they wore and if he can get a duplicate.

Expand full comment